Clearing out old files, I came across my British Economic Organisation exam paper for 1965. At least half the questions are still relevant.
Analysing British Politics
Friday, 20 November 2026
Wednesday, 28 October 2026
Why we are different from Americans: the case of religion.
I have been thinking for some time about reflecting on how my personal relationship with the United States has developed over my lifetime, but I decided initially to focus on one topic: religion.
I was stimulated to do this by finally starting to read the collected letters of the novelist John Updike which I was given last Christmas. Updike is not as widely read as was once the case. Sometimes I think he is too taken up by his talents as a wordsmith and becomes pretentious.
A more serious critique has been developed by feminists in terms of his writing having a particular masculine gaze. This is particularly evident in his semi-autobiographical novel about adultery among 30 something couples in 'Tarbox' (Ipswich, Ma.) The novel is called Couples.
However, I do think that, particularly in the 'Rabbit' novels, he is skilled in portraying the American 'Everyman' of the late 20th century.
There is also a lot about religion in his novels. 'Rabbit' seeks comfort .but with not much success. from his Lutheran pastor. Another novel is about a clergyman who loses his faith.
Updike himself started out as a Congregationalist whilst resenting the 'pinched Unitarianism' of his first wife. He was much more comfortable with the Episcopal affiliation of his second wife and eventually joined this more liberal, less restrictive church.
In American politics, it is very difficult to be an agnostic or atheist (even more so, a Muslim, although that is changing). The Evangelical churches are strong and often politically engaged. President Trump is very ready to misuse religion. He recently claimed endorsement from the Catholic church after he asked visiting bishops to join him in prayer at the White House.
I spent a semester as a guest teacher at an American university. I was somewhat surprised when my sponsor probed my religious beliefs. This would be something of a taboo in the UK. When he learnt that I was a nominal (or agnostic) Anglican, he urged me to attend the local Episcopal cathedral on Palm Sunday and Easter Day. I didn't go, although perhaps I should have done for the experience. I sometimes wonder if I might have been offered a permanent contract if I had agreed.
In Britain, the far right has recently tried to adopt Christianity as a badge of identity whilst having some distance from its core teachings. Fortunately, we believe in the freedom not to worship as well as the freedom to worship.
For me religion is one piece of evidence that we share a similar language with the US, but have a different culture.
Wednesday, 23 September 2026
Lib Dems all at sea
The Lib Dem conference has revealed some discontent with Ed Davey's leadership and the party's failure to make an impact with a distinctive narrative.
Three names were mentioned as possible alternatives, but I had never heard of them. The only other Lib Dems I knew were deputy leader Daisy Cooper - competent but doesn't look like a leader and Alastair Carmichael, the Orkney and Shetland MP. I only know him because he chairs the Defra committee and is wife is a vet who cares for my Orkney friend's dog.
Liberal leader Jo Grimond was the MP for Orkney and Shetland.
The Lib Dems are the most pro EU party, but they have most of those votes already. They also have probably harvested most of the votes from moderate Conservatives who don't like the Tory shift to the right. It wasn't clear how the announced tax cut was to be funded.
I suppose their best hope is that Labour will need their support after the next election and the price will be PR which Andy Burnham favours.
Friday, 18 September 2026
Boomers against Reform
I posted on a private anti-Reform Facebook group a comment that not all older people back Reform or Nigel Farage and the number of likes and comments reached four figures.
There is a clear age gradient in terms of support for Reform (latest available figures):
- 18-24, 6.3%
- 25-29 13.5%
- 30-39 17.1%
- 40-49 20.6%
- 50-59 29.5%
- 60-69 33.7%
- 70+ 33.0%
One has to be careful about accusing Reform supporters of being racists. Rather more may be xenophobes. However, I think that quite a lot of them are what one activist described as 'despairists'. They find it difficult to adjust to the reality of a cosmopolitan 21st century Britain.
I think they are nostalgic for a past that never really existed. I can remember the 1950s (I grew up in London near the docks). I can recall:
- Overt racism (although not from everyone)
- Homophobia
- Pedophiles were there in abundance, but they were white and hiding in plain sight in schools and churches
- Pretensions of imperial grandeur, although these were punctured by Suez
- Pollution: smogs in London that killed thousands of people and you could smell the Thames in summer
- Back street abortions
- Capital punishment used against a woman who was the victim of what we now call coercive control
- A rigid class bound society
Saturday, 22 August 2026
Is Britain's nuclear deterrent cost effective and robust?
With growing Russian threats against the UK this might seem a strange time to question the cost effectiveness of Britain’s nuclear deterrent, but does it offer value for money?
When General Sir Richard Barrons was leading Britain’s Joint
Forces Command, he felt there was always what he described as a “tapeworm”
eating his budget. “Every year we’d think we’d saved a little for something we
needed,” he recalled of his time managing shared capabilities across the
services. “It would always go to the Navy for submarines.” Since then, the
problem has grown, with Britain’s nuclear deterrent consuming a growing share
of the defence budget just as the military is under pressure to re-arm for
conventional war.
The issue, Barrons told the Financial Times, was that
successive governments had postponed costly decisions about Britain’s nuclear
capabilities, leaving several enormous programmes that desperately need to be
modernised at exactly the same time. The result is an unprecedented squeeze on
the rest of Britain’s armed forces. “The UK’s nuclear budget is eating its
conventional budget from the inside,” Barrons, who retired from the role in
2016, told the FT.
Crowding out?
There have been warnings from senior military figures that
the rising cost of the deterrent is crowding out investment in the troops,
ships, missiles and air defences needed to fight today’s wars. Its cost has
taken on added significance as Prime Minister Andy Burnham wrestles with
whether to commit to spending 3 per cent of GDP on defence by 2030 — an issue
over which John Healey, now chancellor, resigned as defence secretary under Sir
Keir Starmer’s government.
The Defence Nuclear Enterprise — the secretive network of
organisations responsible for maintaining the UK’s deterrent — spent more than
£9bn directly with industry in 2024-25, supports about 47,600 jobs and draws on
a supply chain of more than 6,000 companies. By 2030, the government expects
the workforce to swell to roughly 65,000, according to figures published by the
Ministry of Defence on Tuesday.
At the heart of the spending surge are three vast programmes
running in parallel. Britain is building four Dreadnought ballistic-missile
submarines to maintain its continuous at-sea nuclear deterrent; designing and
preparing to manufacture a new generation of attack submarines with Aukus
partners Australia and the US; and developing a replacement for the UK’s
nuclear warhead.
Each is a multibillion-pound undertaking in its own right.
Together, they require Britain to expand nuclear facilities, shipyards and
reactor production, recruit thousands of highly specialised workers and sustain
an industrial base capable of delivering nuclear submarines at a tempo not
attempted for decades. The overall costs of Britain’s nuclear weapons are
difficult to judge as the government does not provide precise breakdowns
compared with the detail provided about most other areas of defence spending.
The defence investment plan, for example, splits many conventional areas into
minute detail but not for nuclear: £47bn is allocated to “submarines” and £13bn
is allocated to “warheads”.
Researchers at the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear
Weapons said the official figures actually overstate the cost because they
include conventionally armed nuclear-powered submarines. Excluding these would
bring the cost from 18 per cent of defence spending in 2025, according to the
MoD, to 14 per cent.
This compares to roughly 11 per cent of defence spending for
France and 7 per cent for the US, according to ICAN. Meanwhile, UK conventional
defence spending is being eclipsed by other Nato countries such as Germany and
Poland, both of which spend more as a percentage of their economies than
Britain.
The need for scrutiny
The vast sums being spent on a new generation of nuclear
weapons and submarines have attracted the attention of parliament. In June, the
Commons’ public accounts committee called for more detail to be provided on
nuclear spending. Subsequently, the government announced the creation of a
committee to scrutinise nuclear spending when parliament returns on September
1. Its evidence sessions will be secret, as will its conclusions, which will be
sent directly to the prime minister and the defence secretary.
Britain’s nuclear weapons have always been seen as an
expensive luxury in exchange for status as a global power. When Clement
Attlee’s government decided in 1947 to proceed with an independent nuclear
deterrent, the Treasury was deliberately excluded from meetings to prevent
financial concerns from blocking the project.
In 1986, the new Trident submarine-launched ballistic
missile system was lampooned on the comedy show Yes, Prime Minister as
unaffordable. “In the world of the nuclear missile it [the Trident] is the
Savile Row suit, the Rolls-Royce Corniche, a Château Lafite 1945. It’s the
nuclear missile that Harrods would sell you,” said one character. But now the
UK nuclear deterrent, which consists of more than 200 warheads on sub-launched
Trident missiles, has become one of the few calling cards the country has left
that ensure it a leading role in Nato.
Despite being operationally independent, the Trident system
is quite reliant on the US for support. Missiles are built in the US and go to
Kings Bay, Georgia, for maintenance. Britain’s new Astraea warhead is jointly
developed with the US W93 warhead programme in order to save costs.
The defence ministry points out launch decisions are made
only by the prime minister. “Our nuclear deterrent is the cornerstone of our
national security,” said an MoD spokesperson. “It is completely operationally
independent and, as we face an increasingly volatile world, it is more
important than ever’
Is it robust?
This does raise questions about how robust it is. The account of the launch procedure that is
in the public domain by Lord Hennessey looks fragile. The prime minister is supposed to use an
underground tunnel to the Ministry of Defence and send a fax to a facility near
High Wycombe.
No surprise, then, that one of the first tasks of an
incoming prime minister is to write a letter to Trident commanders telling them
how to proceed if Britain has already been destroyed.
In practice there are back up arrangements that go beyond
the public account. However, keeping one
submarine at sea has proved difficult given maintenance problems with the
ageing fleet. Crews have had to spend longer
periods at sea away from their families in very cramped conditions (don’t
believe the generous sets in the BBC series Vigil about to be screened in
a third series).
Failings on defence leave Britain cruelly exposed Former
Nato secretary-general Lord George Robertson suggested in testimony to the
defence select committee last month that Britain might eventually need European
allies to help pay for its nuclear deterrent.
[Or perhaps even cooperate with France?]
Yet with defence budgets under sustained pressure and
demands for conventional military capability mounting across Europe, the
question is no longer whether Britain can afford its nuclear deterrent but how
much conventional military power it is prepared to sacrifice in order to
sustain it.
Monday, 10 August 2026
Can Britain reindustralise?
The always perceptive David Smith had an excellent article in the Sunday Times yesterday on deindustrialisation and whether reindustrialisation is a realistic prospect as Andy Burnham hopes.
David Smith hails from the Black Country (as does my wife) and went back there for a school reunion. He discovered more successful industrial firms than he had anticipated, albeit generally SMEs.
In the mid 1970s I went round the West Midlands interviewing a range of firms, mainly SMEs. (The interview transcripts have been lodged with the Modern Records Centre at Warwick University).
I didn't see how these firms could survive and very few of them did. Among the problems I encountered were:
- Insufficient investment
- Complacent managers out of touch with the shop floor, in many cases they couldn't go on it
- Difficult relations with unions in many firms and in particular the shop stewards
- Back offices that seemed to belong to the Victorian era
- A lack of research and development and innovation
- 'Sitting by Nellie' apprenticeships
- Lack of a marketing strategy
This is certainly part of the story, but one must also take account of the liberalisation of international trade under GATT. Low added value metal bashers in the Midlands were swept aside by what were known as the 'newly industrialising countries' with lower labour costs and modern equipment.
Attempts were made by the 1974-9 Labour Government to modernise failing sectors, but it was often too late. In one sector firms forged scrapping certificates for old machinery they were attached to rather than install modern machinery.
According to Smith, Burnham's Labour is focusing on the following industrial sectors: advanced manufacturing; clean energy industries; the creative industries; defence; digital and technologies; financial services; life sciences; and professional and business services — not all of which would have been thought of traditionally as industry. It is all very well supporting the creative industries when the university courses that support them are starved of funds with many staff being sacked. Theatres and museums are also under pressure.
If I take my own town of Leamington or 'Silicon Spa' as it is now known, we have lost:
- Automotive Products who employed around 6,000 to make brakes and clutches, 'there is a part of Leamington in every car. (There is a stun company).
- The Ford foundry, site now occupied by a de luxe furniture factory.
- Pottertons gas boilers
Monday, 3 August 2026
Clacton does not reflect the country as a whole
Conducting a poll in by-election with 34 candidates is not easy, but what we have suggests that Nigel Farage will win 60-70 per cent of the vote in Clacton, but on a smaller turnout. Whether beating someone dressed as a garbage can is a triumph is another matter. Voters there may well get a chance in the autumn to choose between the normal political parties.
It appears that constituents don't care that Farage carries out none of the duties of a constituency MP which would cause a storm in most seats.
I thought it would be interesting to compare Clacton's demographics with those of GB as a whole and my own constituency of Warwick and Leamington. We recently had a town council by-election in my own ward (Royal Clarendon). The Greens won, with the Lib Dems just behind and Labour in touching distance. The Conservatives were way behind and Reform didn't stand.
33 per cent of Clacton voters have what is described as a good education. The figure is 51 per cent nationally and 62 per cent in W & L. Gross household income is £33,147 in Clacton, £42,397 nationally and £46,828 in the Royal Spa and Warwick. Deprivation is indexed at 64 per cent in Clacton, 51 per cent nationally and 43 per cent in my neck of the woods.
The mean age in Clacton is 56.6, as against 49.8 nationally and 47.6 in W & L. Clacton is 96 per cent ethically white compared with 83 per cent nationally and 82 per cent in W & L. We have a large Sikh community and have had a Sikh mayor In addition, there is a large Portuguese speaking population, many of them Brazilians. Areas which have very few ethnic minorities tend to be most concerned about immigration as an issue.
It's interesting that voters who clearly have many economic challenges think that a party backed by billionaires is going to help them surmount then,
.jpg)
